grasping at space



  • If this is your first visit, click here to read "A corollary to the Jarvis Doctrine"
  • Wednesday, June 29, 2005

    Mistaking symbol for reality and government for God

    So once again, Congress is considering a Constitutional amendment to protect the flag, while the US Supreme Court reviews decisions regarding the appropriateness of public displays of the Ten Commandments.

    Alan Watts had the last word on flag burning in 1968:

    “Not long ago Congress voted, with much patriotic rhetoric, for the imposition of severe penalties upon anyone presuming to burn the flag of the United States. Yet the very Congressmen who passed this law are responsible, by acts of commission or omission, for burning, polluting, and plundering the territory that the flag is supposed to represent. Therein, they exemplified the peculiar and perhaps fatal fallacy of civilization: the confusion of symbol with reality.”

    That passage is from the essay “Wealth versus Money,” anthologized in Watts’ book, Does It Matter?

    As for the Decalogue, its Commandments fall into two categories. The first four relate to the individual’s relationship to God, and the final six relate to the individual’s relationship to society.

    Regarding those final six, there are some modern zealots who believe that humanity is so debased and morally stupid that it could never have figured out, without divine intervention, that lying, cheating, stealing and murdering were generally bad ideas. But that is the subject of another blog entry. The first four Commandments are the ones that interest me here.

    When any commandments such as the first four issue forth from a theocratic entity (as the Commandments originally did), the explicit message is that one should be unwaveringly dedicated to one’s God, while the implicit message is that the government is God. When a modern government endorses the public display of the Ten Commandments, it is implicitly demanding a degree of respect that no government ever can deserve.

    To the best of my knowledge, there is no statement to that effect in the dicta of any court decision.

    4 Comments:

    Anonymous jeb said...

    Interesting post.

    I recently had a conversation with a Christian fundamentalist who argued that the ten commandments were the basis of our whole legal system. I pointed out to him, that except for murder and stealing, it wasn't illegal at all to break the other commandments. In fact many respected members of American society broke most of the others frequently. He walked away from the conversation muttering a bit.

    I think there is a fundamental difference between morality and legality - between government and God - that most people simply want to block out. Incredibly, many of these same people I know argued against civil rights legislation because you "can't legislate morality or love."

    Part of the problem is that some people long deeply for a simple world where symbol and reality are the same - where Christ's cross was golden, sparkling, shiny, and inspiring rather than blood drenched - where a set of 10 simple rules tastefully displayed takes care of Columbines and all of the other harsh, difficult-to-solve problems of the day. The symbols become magical touchstones clutched tightly in people's hands as they hurry to catch up with Dorothy to ask the Wizard of Oz to solve their problems too.

    Thu Jul 28, 03:41:00 PM PDT  
    Anonymous Anonymous said...

    中国呼吸网 感冒 支气管炎 气管炎 哮喘 肺癌 肺炎 肺结核 打鼾 鼻炎 咳嗽 咽炎 肺心病 肺气肿 鼻窦炎 鼻息肉 扁桃体炎 喉炎 支气管扩张 肺水肿 肺脓肿 肺不张 尘肺病 肺栓塞 鼻咽癌 鼻窦炎 呼吸衰竭 呼吸道感染 呼吸困难 口咽癌 咽部异物 喉癌 喉麻痹 喉头水肿 新生儿窒息 胸腔积液 气胸 胸膜炎 鼻疖 咯血 胸膜癌 急性会厌炎 禽流感 麻疹 风疹 猩红热 百日咳 呼吸机 氧气机 婉转的夜曲 淋过雨的空气 带著一根烟.浪迹天涯 工作总结

    Mon Jan 21, 06:24:00 PM PST  
    Anonymous Anonymous said...

    好秘书 呼吸网 肿瘤网 中国皮肤网 癌症康复网 演讲稿 竞聘演讲 就职演讲 比赛演讲 征文演讲 节日演讲 演讲技巧 方案制度 工作意见 活动策划 工作方案 整改方案 实施方案 企划文案 销售方案 培训方案 应急预案 材料大全 事迹材料 先进事迹 个人事迹 申报材料 学习材料 考察材料 经验材料 交流材料 自我鉴定 工作计划 工作规划 年度工作计划 学校工作计划 个人工作计划 财务工作计划 团委工作计划 工会工作计划 单位工作计划 德育工作计划 教学工作计划 班主任工作计划 党支部工作计划 先教活动 整改措施 剖析材料 反腐倡廉 三农问题 和谐社会 三个代表 八荣八耻 先进性教育 党团工会 党性分析 民主生活会 入党志愿书 入党申请书 入团申请书 转正申请书 公文写作 板报设计 公文 秘书 广告启事 通知 求职指导 求职信 自荐信 学术论文 企业文化 毕业论文 合同 社交礼仪 哮喘 支气管炎 气管炎 鼻炎 肺癌 呼吸机 氧气机 常用书信 决定不掉泪 一杯咖啡 最熟悉的陌生人 工作总结

    Mon Jan 21, 06:24:00 PM PST  
    Anonymous Anonymous said...

    好秘书 中国呼吸网 肿瘤网 中国皮肤网 癌症康复网 工作总结 肺癌 肝癌 胃癌 肾癌 食道癌 直肠癌 结肠癌 胰腺癌 卵巢癌 宫颈癌 乳腺癌 子宫癌 皮肤癌 鼻咽癌 贲门癌 白血病 骨癌 膀胱癌 前列腺癌 甲状腺癌 脑瘤 尿道癌 舌癌 喉癌 牙癌 胆囊癌 胆管癌 外阴癌 阴茎癌 葡萄胎 淋巴瘤 口腔癌 扁桃体癌 睾丸肿瘤 绒毛膜癌 黑色素瘤 秘书

    Wed Jan 23, 03:04:00 AM PST  

    Post a Comment

    << Home